Fundamentalist American
It's taken me awhile but I have finally come to terms that the GWOT is a crusade. We are fighting a religious war- not of Christianity verus Islam but of Fundamentalist Americanism versus Fundamentalist Islam. It finally makes sense to me. The viciousness of this war is parallel only in other religious wars. It's amorphous, nation-state bouncing nature encompasses much more than what a war used to entail. The GWOT is a war of ideas and beliefs. It is the struggle for dominance between the idea of being an American and the idea of being a Muslim and if we are to win it, we must carefully draw these distinctions to the world.
First of all, what is a Fundamentalist American? This isn't so easy to define. Being an American is commitment to to set of ideas. It's doesn't matter where you come from or who you father was. If you agree to hold faith with the core ideas of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, then we are proud to call you Brother and welcome you with open arms. This is something that cannot be overlooked. The French may grant you citizenship though you may not be ethnically French. There is no American ethnicity so we don't have this squable. We have only the idea. Countries where ethnicity and citizenship are confused often have problems integrating their immigrant populations- something we've so far been quite succesful at. Whatever our problems with racism and we do have them, we have more minorities in high positions in government than any country the in the world. In fact, most Cabinets are usually of one ethnicity. The only realy exception I can think of is Fujimori in Peru. American citizenship being about ideas, our indoctrination is something akin to a religious conversion. Our popluace is more congregation than mass of subjects.
So what separates a Fundamentalist American from another American? I am a Fundamentalist American. I believe in the primacy of American power not because it is always unquestionably good but because it seems to be the surest way to happiness for the greatest amount of people and it has a penchant for self-reflection. Most of the soldiers, Marines and businessmen I know are Fundamentalist Americans too. It's not that we blindly follow the flag. We actively believe in what that flag stands for whether it is pushing Americanism through globalization throughout the world or a ruthless meritocracy that provides the best of us with the best rewards. This is something other nations often fault us for. They hate our ruthlessness, preferring the warm embrace of a soul-sucking, manhood-stealing, inspiration-leeching socialism. It is true that many may fall in the stuggle and their stories may be tragic but I can live with that if the process provides us with the one example that can stir my soul and light the fire in my chest. Striving for excellence has its cost. We are also lambasted for globaliztion- for McDonald's, for EuroDisney and the like. Though these artifaces may lack character, they are distinctively middle-class and able to be enjoyed by practically anyone. More than any other nation in the world, we have pushed wealth down. Say what you want about globalization, the real poverty level in the world has been steadily deacreasing and will continue to do so if market forces are allowed to continue.
When there's talk of who's a "real" American, what is our standard? The only realistic one would have to based on ideas. A Spaniard may say to a Moroccan born and raised in Spain that he's not a real Spaniard because his veins hold no Spanish blood but no ration American would say that even a Daughter of the Mayflower would have the right to say such a thing to the lowliest immigrant who has just taken the oath to be an American. But humans are competitive so we find other ways to say who's more of an American than the other much like you see in some churches. I don't know how many times I've heard stories of conflicts in churches over who was a good or bad Christian.
This brings me back to the GWOT. If you look around most major American cities, you'd never know we were engaged in a way. If you talk to the youth out in bars or clubs, you'd have no idea than their brothers and sisters were out there bleeding adn sweating for them. If you asked them how they felt about it, you'd mostly likely get an answer along the lines of: "I never asked them to go there for me" as if gratefulness was an emotion that burned their skin.
I don't use "fundamentalist" as a pejorative here. For me, it implies strict adherence to an idea or ideal. If you look at it from this point of view, it's clear why the GWOT has been so vicious and why our conflicts are intractable. One of my professors once said that he thought Sesame Street was absolutely the wrong thing to show kids because it gave them the mistaken idea that there is a solution to everything that makes everybody happy. Fundamentalist Americnism and Fundamentalist Islam are diametrically opposed. No amount of talking will ever reconcile them. It is by the sword and sword alone that one will triumph.